
If church discipline is good, why does it feel so unloving? The question deserves a careful answer. A church that handles discipline badly can do real harm, but a church that avoids it altogether does harm of another kind.
Why It Feels Unloving
We live in an age of low accountability and low expectations, particularly when it comes to Christians. Church membership itself is often held in low regard. Our culture encourages us to leave people to themselves, so when a church takes sin seriously, people are quick to assume that it is being harsh.
Yet loving parents hold their children accountable. They help them to structure their lives and, when they break the rules, discipline them out of love and a desire to develop their character and see them flourish. Proverbs makes the point sharply: “Whoever spares the rod hates his son, but he who loves him is diligent to discipline him” (Proverbs 13:24). We see the same principle at work among God’s children in the local church.
There is a second reason why church discipline can feel unloving. Some people have witnessed discipline being administered poorly and without love, and have consequently concluded that discipline itself is unloving. Others may have experienced unloving punishment at home, perhaps administered in anger, and carry that association into their understanding of the church. Both responses are understandable. But the fact that something has been done wrongly does not mean that it is wrong to do.
Why It Is Good
Church discipline is good, first, because Jesus commanded it. He told the church to practise it.
Second, it is good for the sinner’s soul. Imagine someone who has made a profession of faith and been received into the church but has never truly been converted. This person begins to live as though unconverted and persists in sin without repentance. To discipline him is an act of love, because it calls him to examine himself, recognise that he may not be in the faith, and see his need for conversion. Even for a genuine believer, discipline by the church is a gracious warning of the more severe discipline that the Lord himself may bring. The church wants to spare him that.
Third, church discipline is good for the church. It helps to preserve the health of the congregation and prevents it from being corrupted by the leaven of sin.
Most importantly, a healthy church brings glory to Christ.
Discipline, then, is an expression of love towards the sinner. The church does not want him to remain self-deceived. It wants to see him either come to salvation or be restored to the Lord before he experiences the more severe consequences of divine discipline.
Handed to Satan
The language comes from two passages. In 1 Timothy 1:19–20, Paul speaks of those who have made shipwreck of their faith, “among whom are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan that they may learn not to blaspheme”. In 1 Corinthians 5:5, Paul instructs the church to deal similarly with an unrepentant member: “You are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord.”
In the first instance, Paul acted as an apostle. In 1 Corinthians 5, however, he calls the church to take action. What, then, does it mean to hand someone over to Satan?
The church is a called-out assembly. It has been called out by God as a unique society on earth, belonging to him in a special way. It is his bride. To remove someone from church membership, following the process of discipline, is to remove that person from this special sphere of belonging and return him to the world. Paul speaks of “the god of this world” (2 Corinthians 4:4), referring to the world system opposed to God, whose ruler is Satan. In effect, the church is instructed to remove the man from the sphere to which he has been called and return him to the world in which he is behaving as though he belongs.
As for the expression “the destruction of the flesh,” there are different interpretations. My understanding is that the man’s sinful flesh will be exposed. Within the church, a person can hide behind the appearance of godliness. Once removed from the church’s fellowship, the sinful nature that characterises an unbeliever may become increasingly evident. Paul’s desire is that this exposure will lead to repentance. If the man is truly a believer, he will be chastened and, hopefully, return to the church. If he is an unbeliever, he may come to recognise his need for Christ and turn to him in repentance. Alternatively, he may remain in the world, where his conduct suggests he belongs.
Only Two Kingdoms
There are only two kingdoms: the kingdom of Satan and the kingdom of God. Everyone belongs to one or the other; there is no neutral territory. Jesus makes this clear when he speaks of casting out demons and plundering Satan’s kingdom: “Whoever is not with me is against me” (Matthew 12:30).
Many nominal Christians have lost sight of this distinction altogether. Some churches and even entire denominations seem to lack this understanding. In practice, their approach can suggest that everyone is saved simply because they attend church or have been baptised. But Scripture teaches that those who do not belong to God’s family and kingdom remain under Satan’s dominion.
When someone behaves as though he belongs to Satan’s kingdom, church discipline formally removes him from the fellowship of God’s people and treats him accordingly. It is a recognition that his conduct is inconsistent with the profession he has made. If he is truly a believer, the hope is that this discipline will awaken him to repentance and bring him back into fellowship.
When Does a Church Take This Step?
The first ground for church discipline is persistent, unrepentant sin. Matthew 18, among other passages, addresses this situation. A church member is confronted with sin but refuses to repent.
Some sins are so grievous that they require urgent action, such as the flagrant immorality described in 1 Corinthians 5. Other situations are less clear-cut and may involve persistent non-attendance, attitudinal problems, or settled patterns of behaviour. In these cases, the church must exercise patience. Over time, however, if it becomes clear that there is no willingness to repent, the church must proceed to the final step of removing the person from membership.
All Christians are sinners, and the Christian life is one of continual repentance. The question is not whether someone is a weaker or less mature believer. It is whether there is a persistent refusal to repent.
Ready to Restore
I have seen the fruit of restoration in my own church and ministry over the years. When it comes to restoring someone, we should look for a reversal of the behaviour that led to discipline: a lifestyle characterised by repentance, accompanied by fruit that demonstrates its genuineness.
I would not rush to restore someone, any more than I would rush to excommunicate someone, although some situations demand urgent action. The church should walk patiently with the individual for the sake of his soul, seeking to establish whether his repentance is genuine.
Paul distinguishes between godly grief and worldly grief: “For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death” (2 Corinthians 7:10). Some people are simply sorry that they were caught or that they have lost the privileges and benefits of church membership. Their regret does not necessarily reflect a changed heart. Where genuine repentance has taken place, however, there will be evidence of it. When that evidence becomes clear, the person can be restored to membership.
How Long?
I do not believe there is a divinely prescribed timeline for restoration. Each situation must be considered on its own merits. Where the sin involved gross immorality, for example, the church must probe carefully to ensure that there are no hidden issues and that repentance is genuine. At the same time, a church must exercise wisdom without becoming unnecessarily scrupulous.
Consider a man who has been removed from membership because he has failed to attend church for six months. He comes forward and says, “I repent,” and then turns up the following Sunday. I would hesitate to immediately restore him to membership. I would want to see whether there is a genuine appetite for fellowship and whether that desire is sustained over time. This is for his own good and for the good of the church.
In practice, this involves pastoring, counselling, and discipling the professing penitent. At my own church, our membership process is intentionally lengthy. After attending a membership information class, a prospective member works through ten lessons with an existing church member, focused on understanding the church and church membership. This takes at least ten weeks, followed by the completion of a membership application and an interview with the elders. All told, the process takes at least fourteen to sixteen weeks—sometimes longer.
I would not require someone being restored to go through the entire process again. Instead, I would fast-track the process, concentrating on the issues that led to discipline and addressing those matters carefully.
Converted Under Discipline
Suppose someone was never saved, was excommunicated, and then genuinely came to faith while outside the church. Should that person be baptised?
I would be very open to it. If the person was not previously saved, his baptism was simply an outward act without the corresponding inward reality. Baptism follows a profession of faith, and if that profession was not genuine, there is good reason to consider baptism following conversion.
I would, of course, want to exercise care here, because people can sometimes confuse spiritual growth with conversion. But if it is clear that genuine conversion has taken place, I would baptise that person.
Doing It Well
Church discipline is good and biblical, but it must be approached carefully. When administered badly, it departs from the biblical pattern and can cause considerable harm.
It is no coincidence that the words “discipline” and “discipling” look so similar. They are closely related. If someone is discipled through the process of discipline, that process can only be an expression of love. Indeed, where intentional discipleship has been taking place long before discipline becomes necessary, the process rarely ends in excommunication, because sin is addressed early.
The Bible also speaks of the wisdom found in many counsellors. Involving a number of people in the process helps to ensure that discipline is administered wisely, fairly and lovingly.
